An Overview of Policy Options
for Changing the Tort System
Various scholars and policy advocates have
proposed altering the tort liability system
to reduce what they see as excessive transaction
costs and other problems associated with
it. Those proposals are too numerous for
all of them to be discussed here. Instead,
this chapter examines a number of policy
options to illustrate the range of choices
available to lawmakers. The chapter outlines
each option's potential implications for
efficiency and equity. For reasons of space,
however, it cannot analyze any one option
in full detail. (For example, it does not
consider the effects on state law or the
potential transition problems associated
with a particular change, nor does it discuss
the many possibilities for combining policies
that are not mutually exclusive.)
The options discussed here can be grouped
according to their general approach. The
first approach would greatly reduce the
scope of the tort system and rely more heavily
on other tools to control the costs of injuries.
The second group contains options that are
more incremental in nature but that could
be applied broadly to the universe of torts.
The final set comprises options targeted
toward types of tort claims that have raised
particular policy concerns, such as claims
arising from medical malpractice or asbestos
exposure and those litigated as class actions.
In all three groups, most of the proposals
can be seen as addressing one or more of
the fundamental barriers to efficiency discussed
in Chapter 3:
The difficulty of giving both potential
injurers and potential victims incentives
to choose the efficient form and scale of
their risk-related activities;
The added difficulty of optimally distributing
(insuring) the risks that remain after efficient
precautions have been taken; and
Problems relating to the cost and scarcity
of information, including transaction costs,
errors in judgments and in settlements,
and inefficient standards for due care.
Other options respond to issues that arise
from broader aspects of the legal system,
such as the perceived problem that some
locally elected judges are biased against
out-of-state corporate defendants.
Options for Reducing the Scope of Tort
Liability
The policy changes in this group--which
involve replacing some or all types of tort
liability with private or public insurance--generally
go well beyond the kinds of proposals now
being considered by the Congress. They are
included here because they help clarify
the strengths and weaknesses of the tort
system or provide useful comparisons with
other options.
Lawsuits Consumer Fraud
(St. Paul, Minn.: West Group, 1999), p. 926.
More...
Lawsuits Consumer Fraud
26, no. 2 (June 1997). 18. George L.
More...
New York Lawyers Information
Instead of pursuing only a selected subset of the alleged injurers (often just the single party with the deepest pockets) and shifting the costs of dealing with the remaining parties to that selected group, plaintiffs must sue everyone from whom they hope to collect damages.
More...
Lawsuits Consumer Fraud Class Actions Securities Lawyers - Complaint Center
This basically means that the victim is being accused of knowingly exposing themselves to the harm that ultimately injured them. Although one cannot consent to everything, e.g., murder, consent (if proven) can help the defendant defeat the victim's case. Finally, victims may be accused of contributing to their own injuries.
More...
Product Recall Safety Legal and Lawyer Attorney Resources
Consumer Product Safety Information: official website, including recalls, reports, lawyers, attorneys, class action, lawsuits, settlements and alerts such ... www.productrecallsafetyalerts.com/ - 20k -
More...
Product Recall Safety Legal and Lawyer Attorney Resources
Consumer Product Safety Information: official website, including recalls, reports, lawyers, attorneys, class action, lawsuits, settlements and alerts such ... www.productrecallsafetyalerts.com/ - 20k -
More...
Class Action Lawsuits Consumer Fraud Class Actions Securities Lawyers - Complaint Center
T.S. 320 (Oct. 21, 1994), and thus defines the scope of the United States' obligations under the treaty. See Relevance of Senate Ratification History to Treaty Interpretation, 11 Op. O.L.C. 28, 32-33 (1987).
More...
Class Action Lawsuit Lawyers and Attorneys - Pfizer maker of Celebrex
The Kahn Gauthier Law Group and Class Action Lawsuit Lawyers and Attorneys are investigating possible legal actions after medical studies raised concerns ... www.classactionamerica.com/affiliates/ gm/classactionlawsuit.asp?lngCaseID=1210 - 62k -
More...
Class Action Lawsuit Lawyers and Attorneys - Pfizer maker of Celebrex
The Kahn Gauthier Law Group and Class Action Lawsuit Lawyers and Attorneys are investigating possible legal actions after medical studies raised concerns ... www.classactionamerica.com/affiliates/ gm/classactionlawsuit.asp?lngCaseID=1210 - 62k -
More...
[1]